Hello Dalton,
We are sorry that the 319 formula did not meet your expectation and when it comes to scent, it is so personal. Our 319 formula is fragrance free which means there is no additional fragrance from a perfumer added but you might smell a hint of extracts, citrus essential oils and the menthol.
Since everyone has a different sense of smell and being such a personal choice, we do have a 30 day return policy so please feel free to contact us at 888-670-3756 or CustomerService@ChazDean.com and we can assist you.